Skip to main content

Film review · 2002

Minority Report

**1/2

Reviewed by: Angus Wolfe Murray

Minority Report

There is a fine line between fascination and bafflement. Minority Report steps over that line. Without intimate knowledge of Philip K Dick's short story, upon which this is based, you will need three viewings to understand what is going on. At 145 minutes a pop, that's seven-and-a-half hours to unravel the science that clothes a B-picture plot.

The year is 2054. Life is not so different, except some vehicles fly and haircuts remain short and ruttish. Obsession with security continues, with the FBI poking its nose into other people's business, while police techniques have taken an unexpectedly imaginative leap forward.

Copy pictureChief Paul Anderton (Tom Cruise) heads a PreCrime unit. The idea is that by anticipating murder before it happens, you can avoid it. Aided by PreCogs, perceptive individuals with psychic powers, cops can "see" a killing in advance. Having deciphered the exact location from clues within the "dream", they rush to the scene and arrest the perpetrator in the act of thinking about doing the deed.

Anderton is a tortured soul. He lost his only son and is estranged from his wife. He lives for his work and, as a result, is not a happy bunny. When the FBI, headed by a dapper agent (Colin Farrell), starts making enquiries into his unit's activities, he takes a dim view. Little does he know that he's being set up as a fall guy in a devious political ploy, concerning the future of PreCrime.

Or something... This may be completely misleading. Who's to tell? Elaborate special effects take centre screen, so that the human story is pushed to one side. There is no character development whatsoever. Samantha Morton, as a PreCog, spends most of the movie in a coma, floating in a pool. Farrell has style, but no content, and Cruise, for once, looks weighed down by the responsibility of his role. Anderton is two-dimensional and Cruise cannot start his heart beating.

There is little indication that this is a Steven Spielberg film. The master storyteller has been seduced by the lure of technology. Even his trademark sentimentality is missing.

In order to feel you need to empathise and in order to empathise you need to come close. It doesn't happen. There are too many gadgets in the way.

Reviewed on: 03 Jul 2002

Source JustWatch

If you like this, try:

Blade Runner: The Director's Cut
Review preview for Blade Runner: The Director's Cut

It is among the most unwavering make-believe worlds I have ever seen in cinema... I can only wish the film's story lingered anywhere near as much as it's artistry.

Scott Macdonald · 3 out of 5
A Scanner Darkly
Review preview for A Scanner Darkly

It's difficult to imagine any fan of Dick's failing to adore this film; but as it retains the genius of his work, so it retains the flaws, and this could be a big problem for some other viewers.

Jennie Kermode · 4.5 out of 5
Watchmen
Review preview for Watchmen

A sprawling epic of our times – and all times.

Anton Bitel · 4 out of 5