Skip to main content

Reviews by Andrew Robertson

Order by: Date, A–Z

  • Detective Dee And The Mystery Of The Phantom Flame (2010)
    Review preview for Detective Dee And The Mystery Of The Phantom Flame

    Sammo Hung provides the action sequences, there are model shots and good old fashioned matte painting and the costumes - oh, my, the costumes.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    When spontaneous combustion claims the lives of several members of her court, an empress calls on the brilliant and inventive Detective Dee to solve the mystery.
  • Spider Fang! (2010)
    Review preview for Spider Fang!

    The only things that stop it from being perfect are boring technical ones.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A small girl's game with her grandfather takes an unexpected and sinister turn.
  • Narrow Gauge (2010)
    Review preview for Narrow Gauge

    The small cast (and the rat) offer good performances.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    A couple struggling with their inability to have a baby are haunted by a rat in the walls.
  • Mokhtar (2010)
    Review preview for Mokhtar

    A stunning debut.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    A boy brings home an injured bird only to be rejected by his father, who is convinced that it is a demon.
  • In A Pig's Eye (2010)
    Review preview for In A Pig's Eye

    There is a beauty to it, a sort of quasi-legendary feel, a tickling, yawning surrealism.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A quiet little Japanese farm is dominated by an enormous pig.
  • The Worm Inside (2010)
    Review preview for The Worm Inside

    Striking, moving, like being given someone's diary to read.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A woman considers her diagnosis of Grave's disease, and the strange treatments on offer.
  • The Long Walk Of The Chameleon (2010)
    Review preview for The Long Walk Of The Chameleon

    It has good performances, especially from the chameleon.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A journey is interrupted by the sighting of a chameleon, which presages ill fortune.
  • The Company Men (2010)
    Review preview for The Company Men

    It's well directed but even if most of the cast weren't phoning it in they would have real difficulty eliciting sympathy.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Three corporate executives struggle to come to terms with losing their jobs.
  • XXIX (2010)
    Review preview for XXIX

    It's visually complex, impressive aurally, and a treat.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Twenty-one Canadian singers perform a contemporary resetting of a 15th century choral piece, each one singing in their ancestral language.
  • Checkpoint (2010)
    Review preview for Checkpoint

    The heart of the film is Abdallah El Akal as Suleiman.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    An 11-year-old Palestinian boy accompanies his father on regular trips to a ruined Gaza village, though he doesn't understand their purpose.
  • X.O. Genesis (2010)
    Review preview for X.O. Genesis

    It's originality in service of homage, derivative more than it is diverting.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    An alien who has crashed in Earth finds different religions and ideologies calling to him as he explores the unfamiliar landscape.
  • Wood Of Value (2010)
    Review preview for Wood Of Value

    Unfortunately, documentaries about interesting subjects are not intrinsically interesting.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A documentary following a special Christmas tree on its journey across the North Sea from Norway to London.
  • The Barbarians (2010)
    Review preview for The Barbarians

    This feels more like something you'd be linked to through Facebook than something you'd go to see in the picturehouse.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    An experimental exploration of the barbarian spirit.
  • Flag Mountain (2010)
    Review preview for Flag Mountain

    It's good, even stripped of one of its two elements, and it might be very good.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    An introduction to the city of Nicosia, torn between Greek Cypriot and Turkish influences.
  • Surpriseville (2010)
    Review preview for Surpriseville

    It leaves a few too many questions unanswered, a few too many unasked, but it's still excellent.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    An exploration of the fears and anxieties that haunt a gated community in Arizona.
  • The Adjustment Bureau (2011)
    Review preview for The Adjustment Bureau

    There's a lot of good work here, decent performances from Blunt, Damon and Mackie, some gorgeous locations and some neat production design, but it doesn't quite work.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    When a man meets a beautiful woman for the second time, the plans the mysterious Adjustment Bureau have for his life go awry.
  • Party (2009)
    Review preview for Party

    Written and directed by Dalibor Matanic, with a strong central performance from Leona Paraminski, it's technically adept, haunting.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A Vukovar girl takes in the delights of a simple summer day spent with friends.
  • Vapor (2010)
    Review preview for Vapor

    Dedicated to its inspiration, it's a touching film, visually impressive and well constructed.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A Mexican man discovers that life becomes richer when he challenges his own prejudices.
  • Old Fangs (2009)
    Review preview for Old Fangs

    While there's good technique on display it's not as captivating as animation can be.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    A young wolf whose mother has left gets his friends to support him in confronting his absent father.
  • Caretaker For The Lord (2009)
    Review preview for Caretaker For The Lord

    With excellent sound work, a keen eye and a good subject, this is a lovely piece of documentary.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    A documentary about the community in a neglected Glasgow church and their struggle for survival.
  • Low Tide (2009)
    Review preview for Low Tide

    For the visual quality alone this is worth seeing.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    A lonely man one winter afternoon undertakes a strange journey without leaving his room.
  • Madagascar, A Journey Diary (2009)
    Review preview for Madagascar, A Journey Diary

    It's a masterclass, an unfair degree of talent for a film-maker's debut, full of subtleties of sound and vision.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    A video game director uses the tricks of his trade to recreate his experiences on a trip to Madagascar.
  • Lin (2010)
    Review preview for Lin

    Lin Clifton carries the film. She is haunted, haunting.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    A mysterious woman arrives at dawn in an unknown country, fleeing some terrible secret in her past.
  • Mrdrchain (2010)
    Review preview for Mrdrchain

    After a while, I started hallucinating, and developed a tumor.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Slicemen struggle to get by amid terrifying shadows in the land of the murderchain.
  • Shadows of Silence (2010)
    Review preview for Shadows of Silence

    It is haunting, mysterious.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A depressed man living in exile with his young family longs for the culture and homeland he left behind.
  • Canopy Crossings (2010)
    Review preview for Canopy Crossings

    This is a slight film, but that's not problematic because of its greatest feature; it is suffused with colour, saturated, possessed of a tremendous sense of place.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Three people working in a local market dream of bigger things, but everything must stop eight times a day to pull down the canopy and make way for passing trains.
  • Promise (2010)
    Review preview for Promise

    The complexity of the piece never causes it to stumble.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    When an impoverished mother promises her son will become great, only an old man believes her, and he makes the boy make a promise of his own.
  • Lihya (2010)
    Review preview for Lihya

    The real questions are about why it is that we are watching what we are watching, why it was that it was made.

    Andrew Robertson · 1 out of 5
    A documentary about a Damascan barbershop provides an opportunity for a haircut, a shave and an Arabic lesson.
  • If Only I Was Simone De Beauvoir (2010)
    Review preview for If Only I Was Simone De Beauvoir

    There's something interesting here, but it's an arch construct without foundation.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Experimental short.
  • The External World (2010)
    Review preview for The External World

    It's well executed, voiced, a sitcom segment has the hollow laughter of canned audiences down pat, but its targets are soft, safe, staid.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    An animated short about a boy learning to play the piano and to express himself in new ways.
  • Tord & Tord (2010)
    Review preview for Tord & Tord

    The film is brilliant. Not unique in intent, let us not make that mistake, but moving, affecting, at once subdued and inviting.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    When Tord comes home he finds that his apartment has subtly changed and is inhabited by a stranger, also called Tord.
  • Deafness (2010)
    Review preview for Deafness

    This might almost be mime, were it not, well, brilliant.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A mute man is arrested in a short film devoid of audible words.
  • The Accordion (2010)
    Review preview for The Accordion

    For all its import this feels like stereotypical Iranian cinema.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    When their accordion is confiscated, two children contemplate the meaning or acceptance, resistance and meaningful political struggle.
  • Photos Of God (2010)
    Review preview for Photos Of God

    It's good, even very good, but there are moments that weaken it.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A teenage boy looks after his disabled mother as both wrestle with memories of how life used to be.
  • For You I Will Fight (2010)
    Review preview for For You I Will Fight

    Well directed, well judged, subtle in tone and form.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Escaping from an unhappy love affair, a young woman enlists in the army to try and find meaning in her life.
  • Boxer (2010)
    Review preview for Boxer

    This is a debut feature, and while strong in places it doesn't quite gel.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A lonely man in a run-down corner of Scotland finds his life transformed after he witnesses a violent attack.
  • The Pedestrian (2010)
    Review preview for The Pedestrian

    While the Pedestrian is humorous and confidently acted it still manages to slow in places.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Jonathon Collins has never been beaten at any walking competition, and joins them eagerly on his daily commute. But could his obsession jeopardise a possible romance with a young woman who walks for charity?
  • The Way Back (2010)
    Review preview for The Way Back

    The story is a singular achievement, but the film is overly episodic.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Soldiers escaping from a Siberian gulag decide to walk all the way to India.
  • The Tourist (2010)
    Review preview for The Tourist

    There are moments of distress, high tension, but there's never much doubt that there will be a happy ending.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A post-heist thriller about a man whose lonely wanderings lead him into the path of a dangerous woman with still more dangerous enemies.
  • Paradise Later (2010)
    Review preview for Paradise Later

    Sometimes the sense of a thing is enough, and Paradise Later delivers ably.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Shots of pollution in an Indonesian river are accompanied by the sounds of a travelling salesman reporting to his board.
  • State Of Flux (Wave #1) (2009)
    Review preview for State Of Flux (Wave #1)

    Only just avoids outstaying its welcome.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Exploring the nature of chaotic systems through the examination of water.
  • What Part of the Earth Is Inhabited (After Pliny the Elder) (2009)
    Review preview for What Part of the Earth Is Inhabited (After Pliny the Elder)

    Messy, seeming unmoderated.

    Andrew Robertson · 1.5 out of 5
    Exploration of evolution and life.
  • De Luce 1: Vegetare (2009)
    Review preview for De Luce 1: Vegetare

    Hand-processed super8 film makes patterns, colours, shapes that raise questions about technique, origin, which remain unanswered.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Super 8/digital hybrid experimental film, exploring use of colour.
  • Scene 32 (2009)
    Review preview for Scene 32

    Visually impressive, technically proficient, Scene 32 impresses the eyes.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Avant garde depiction of the salt fields of central Kaatch.
  • Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps (2010)
    Review preview for Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps

    There are loads of characters, tonnes of things going on, and little to no reason to invest.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Gordon Gecko is back, and this time he's predicting financial disaster.
  • Grim's Dyke (2010)
    Review preview for Grim's Dyke

    The film itself is a thing attacked, artifact upon medium transformed by light into something inexplicable.

    Andrew Robertson · 2.5 out of 5
    Experimental short.
  • Lumphini 2552 (2009)
    Review preview for Lumphini 2552

    Three minutes that are thing and un-thing, a flicker of stillness.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Avant garde film using still photography captured in Bangkok's Lumphini Park.
  • Trees Of Syntax, Leaves Of Axis (2009)
    Review preview for Trees Of Syntax, Leaves Of Axis

    Dachi Sato's film is striking, the flicker of light through trees like rolling down a forested lane.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Examination of maple trees set to a contrapuntal violin score.
  • Gathering (2009)
    Review preview for Gathering

    Conveys mood and beauty ably but never quite grabs.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Traces of the spring.
  • Journal And Remarks (2009)
    Review preview for Journal And Remarks

    What grates is that the film cannot stand alone, but more so that even with support it falters.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Images from the Galapagos intermingle with pages from Darwin's book A Voyage Of The Beagle.

News and features

Paul Rowley on moving to New York, the Pulse massacre, and Gays Against Guns

'It was written for him' Declan Recks on comedy drama One Sweet Hour and its late star Gary Lydon

All at sea Max Fisher on refugee journeys, anti-migrant sentiment and Rule, Britannia

Fishing for identity Pete Muller on questions of masculinity and how it passes down the generations in Bucks Harbor

A step ahead of the others Leading Italian filmmakers on the legacy of Robert Rossellini

True to her nature Hanna Bergholm on storytelling, emotional truth and Nightborn

Painting history Pauline Julier and Nicolas Chapoulier on imagining the journey of a 17th century portait in Les Indes

Fatherland leads European Film Awards nominations La Bola Negra hot on its heels

More news and features

Festival coverage

Festivals
Cannes festival coverage, 2026

We're bringing you all the latest news and reviews from the Cheltenham International Film Festival, the Leeds International Film Festival, the Thessaloniki International Film Festival and Tallinn Black Nights.



We're looking forward to the French Film Festival and DOC NYC.



We've recently brought you coverage of the Belfast Film Festival, Halloween Frightfest, the Scottish Queer International Film Festival, Newfest, the London Film Festival, the New York Film Festival and Grimmfest.



Read our full for more.


Visit our festivals section.