Skip to main content

Reviews by Andrew Robertson

Order by: Date, A–Z

  • The Other Lamb (2019)
    Review preview for The Other Lamb

    The Other Lamb is oneiric, pareidoliac, one where faces are painted and set, possessed of an immediate mythic weight.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A young girl begins to question her place in the religious community she was born into.
  • Our Ladies (2019)
    Review preview for Our Ladies

    It feels a bit like a box-ticking exercise at a funding body.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Comedy drama sees a group of choirgirls on a day trip to Edinburgh.
  • The Outfit (2022)
    Review preview for The Outfit

    The Outfit isn't doing anything new, but it does it all incredibly well.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    An expert tailor must outwit a dangerous group of mobsters in order to survive a fateful night.
  • Ottery (2015)
    Review preview for Ottery

    Less traditional but perhaps stronger for it.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A mysterious glimpse of an England steeped in folkloric tradition.
  • Outpost 3: Rise Of The Spetsnaz (2013)
    Review preview for Outpost 3: Rise Of The Spetsnaz

    Outpost 3's menagerie of menace is a muddle.

    Andrew Robertson · 1 out of 5
    A member of Russia's elite special forces must battle to survive after he is captured by the Nazis and comes face to face with their grotesque zombie experiments.
  • Out Of The Ashes (2010)
    Review preview for Out Of The Ashes

    A film with moments of striking beauty, compassion, and more than a few sporting thrills.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    The story of the unexpected rise and rise of the Afghan cricket team.
  • Palimpsest (2006)
    Review preview for Palimpsest

    While seeming to aim for Lynchian depth, Palimpsest doesn't quite manage it.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    A Polish detective investigates the murder of a colleague.
  • Pandas (2012)
    Review preview for Pandas

    Pandas is gleeful, brutal, mischievous and funny.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Animated tale about the clash for space between pandas and humans.
  • Paradise In Service (2014)
    Review preview for Paradise In Service

    Despite the lush colour this is bleak, even heart-breaking.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    War drama set against the backdrop of a military brothel.
  • Paradise Later (2010)
    Review preview for Paradise Later

    Sometimes the sense of a thing is enough, and Paradise Later delivers ably.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Shots of pollution in an Indonesian river are accompanied by the sounds of a travelling salesman reporting to his board.
  • Paris/Sexy (2010)
    Review preview for Paris/Sexy

    Both compelling and haunting.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    A girl on the verge of womanhood imagines life away from the constraints of caring for her father.
  • Parliamo Glasgow (2009)
    Review preview for Parliamo Glasgow

    This is a touching little film.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    Coming to grips with the Glaswegian dialect...?
  • Party (2009)
    Review preview for Party

    Written and directed by Dalibor Matanic, with a strong central performance from Leona Paraminski, it's technically adept, haunting.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A Vukovar girl takes in the delights of a simple summer day spent with friends.
  • Pecking Order (2017)
    Review preview for Pecking Order

    Though it finds humour, and may even be poking fun on occasion, it never feels disrespectful.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    Documentary investigates the world of New Zealand chicken breeders.`
  • Perfect Garden (2013)
    Review preview for Perfect Garden

    Turning a sandwich upside-down does not tend to constitute innovation.

    Andrew Robertson · 1 out of 5
    A surreal and visceral journey into human desire.
  • A Perfect Getaway (2009)
    Review preview for A Perfect Getaway

    This is a fun film, genuinely exciting, twisty like the mountain trails, with uncertain footing throughout.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Two couples walking on a remote trail hear over the radio that a couple of psychopaths are on the loose.
  • Photos Of God (2010)
    Review preview for Photos Of God

    It's good, even very good, but there are moments that weaken it.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    A teenage boy looks after his disabled mother as both wrestle with memories of how life used to be.
  • Pierrot Lunaire (2014)
    Review preview for Pierrot Lunaire

    It has been described in places as "very funny" but it's closer to laughable.

    Andrew Robertson · 1 out of 5
    A transgender cabaret performer falls tragically in love with a young woman.
  • Pig In A Poke (2009)
    Review preview for Pig In A Poke

    The animation is crisp, the character design entertaining.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A ventriloquist butcher finds himself in conflict with his pig puppet.
  • Pilgrimage (2011)
    Review preview for Pilgrimage

    In Pilgrimage there is a journey, but one is not certain if it is intentional that there is nothing at the end.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    A stroll through the Parc Lafontaine in Montreal reveals moments of wonder.
  • Pirates Of The Caribbean: On Stranger Tides (2011)
    Review preview for Pirates Of The Caribbean: On Stranger Tides

    A genuinely entertaining outing for the series, managing to generate both novelty and surprise while preserving all the best features of the preceding pictures.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Jack Sparrow is forced to accompany a dangerous woman and her still more dangerous ally on a daring quest to find the legendary Fountain of Youth.
  • A Play for Freedom (2012)
    Review preview for A Play for Freedom

    Apfel's film just watches, even surveils.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Is censored art better than no art at all?
  • Plot Point (2007)
    Review preview for Plot Point

    It's a brilliant piece, almost wasted in a cinema because it's only seen once.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    At a big event in Times Square, something is going on - but what?
  • Police Adjective (2009)
    Review preview for Police Adjective

    This is a police procedural, but it's also about the nature of policing, about the gap between law and justice, the self and the state.

    Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
    A young policeman crosses swords with his supervisor when he hesitates to turn in a teen caught with drugs.
  • Possessed (2010)
    Review preview for Possessed

    Among the dropped frames it seems more forced than it ought, less critical.

    Andrew Robertson · 1 out of 5
    Watching Joan Crawford watching life go by.
  • Pacific Rim: Uprising (2018)
    Review preview for Pacific Rim: Uprising

    At the most basic level, giant robots fighting monsters in the middle of Tokyo. Ultimately everything else sort of falls by the wayside.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    Kaiju return to threaten human civilisation, and once again only giant robots can stop them.
  • Parallel Mothers (2021)
    Review preview for Parallel Mothers

    Milena Smit is a relative newcomer. This is only her second feature and she has real presence.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    Two women, a generation apart, find themselves inextricably linked by their brief time together in a maternity ward, bound by a secret with ties to a deep trauma in Spanish history.
  • Paraphernalia (2009)
    Review preview for Paraphernalia

    Paraphernalia is a product of a significant team effort, and it shows in its quality.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Atari struggles with his useless robot, but his real struggle is more complex.
  • Passage Upon The Plume (2011)
    Review preview for Passage Upon The Plume

    There's a suggestion that this is out of time, a zephyr inconstant, a mystery of the air and the shifting sands.

    Andrew Robertson · 2.5 out of 5
    A series of observations of buildings and inventions, everything rising up into the sky.
  • The Pedestrian (2010)
    Review preview for The Pedestrian

    While the Pedestrian is humorous and confidently acted it still manages to slow in places.

    Andrew Robertson · 3 out of 5
    Jonathon Collins has never been beaten at any walking competition, and joins them eagerly on his daily commute. But could his obsession jeopardise a possible romance with a young woman who walks for charity?
  • Penelope (2006)
    Review preview for Penelope

    As a modern fairy tale Penelope has a gentle touch, and while flat in places it's definitely more silk purse than sow's ear.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    A young heiress is disfigured by a curse which only true love can lift.
  • The Perfect Fit (2011)
    Review preview for The Perfect Fit

    It takes a special kind of documentarian to look behind the right curtain.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    A look at the craft of making ballet shoes and the damage done in the pursuit of art.
  • Phantom Of The Paradise (1974)
    Review preview for Phantom Of The Paradise

    Again and again there are elements that will be echoed in later works, mirrors and masks and little friends, split screens and thrills and untimely ends.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A disfigured composer sells his soul for the woman he loves so that she will perform his music - but an evil record tycoon betrays him and steals his music to open his rock palace, The Paradise.
  • Pig (2021)
    Review preview for Pig

    Cage fills the screen even when he does not.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    A truffle hunter who lives alone in the Oregonian wilderness is forced to return to his past in Portland in search of his beloved foraging pig after she is kidnapped
  • Pile Of Salt (2021)
    Review preview for Pile Of Salt

    Marc Camardon's film, co-written with Jordi Tortosa, explores familiar themes with verve.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A diligent and faithful Catholic seminarist, experiences a crisis after meeting a fellow student.
  • A Place To Come (2011)
    Review preview for A Place To Come

    An intriguing piece.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    Descriptions and realities are at odds in this experimental short.
  • Plane (2023)
    Review preview for Plane

    As functional as Plane is, it's nuts and bolts, by the numbers, and for much of the time pedestrian.

    Andrew Robertson · 2.5 out of 5
    A pilot finds himself caught in a war zone after he's forced to land his commercial aircraft during a terrible storm.
  • Please Don't Destroy: The Treasure Of Foggy Mountain (2023)
    Review preview for Please Don't Destroy: The Treasure Of Foggy Mountain

    The Treasure Of Foggy Mountain isn't worth leaving home for, and to be honest I'm not sure it's worth any time on your sofa either.

    Andrew Robertson · 2 out of 5
    Three friends realise that they don't like their life trajectory, so set off in search of a golden treasure that is rumored to be buried on the nearby mountain.
  • Podesta Island (2020)
    Review preview for Podesta Island

    Stephanie Roland's film exists in a space between spaces, a liminal latitude, languorous longitude, a tropic of candour.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    In a hyperconnected and mapped world, are there still unknown areas?
  • Polite Society (2023)
    Review preview for Polite Society

    There's unbridled talent on display here, behind and before the camera.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Aspiring martial artist Ria Khan believes she must save her older sister, Lena, from her impending marriage. With the help of her friends, Ria attempts to pull off the most ambitious of all wedding heists in the name of independence and sisterhood.
  • Pornography (2009)
    Review preview for Pornography

    In her directorial debut, Jo McInnes shows a confident touch and a keen eye.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    A brother and sister experience crises together.
  • Postcode Lottery (2012)
    Review preview for Postcode Lottery

    This isn't a conventional life-affirming cancer narrative, this is angrier, more personal.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    Unable to access cancer treatment, Jed resorts to desperate measures.
  • Pouters (2012)
    Review preview for Pouters

    There are some stunning shots, neat personal moments.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    Two longtime rivals battle for the title of Doo Fleein Champion in the East End of Glasgow.
  • Power Ballad (2026)
    Review preview for Power Ballad

    Taking care of business is rarely as emotional, but it's part of Power Ballad's exploration of authenticity.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    When a past-his-prime wedding singer meets a fading boy-band star during a gig, the two bond over music and a late-night jam session, but then the former star turns one of the wedding singer’s songs into the hit that reignites his career.
  • The Power Of The Dog (2021)
    Review preview for The Power Of The Dog

    That is the strength of adaptation, to find in the words and the spaces between them new rhythms, new visions.

    Andrew Robertson · 4.5 out of 5
    A widow and her son are tormented by her new husband’s sullen and bullying brother.
  • Practice (2022)
    Review preview for Practice

    It's rare to see the near-naked intimacy here outwith a documentary context.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A man tries to pluck up the courage to get into the dating game, but his nerves get the better of him.
  • Predator: Badlands (2025)
    Review preview for Predator: Badlands

    The bones of the story are familiar but this is new flesh upon them, a vital bit of rejuvenation and not tedious taxidermy.

    Andrew Robertson · 3.5 out of 5
    A young Predator outcast from his clan finds an unlikely ally on his journey in search of the ultimate adversary.
  • Predator: Killer Of Killers (2025)
    Review preview for Predator: Killer Of Killers

    I hugely enjoyed Prey, was amused by Badlands, but I spent almost all of Killer Of Killers grinning so widely I nearly grew mandibles.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    An original animated action-adventure film set in the Predator universe.
  • A Present Light (2021)
    Review preview for A Present Light

    Jorge Quintela's cinematography finds grandeur in what could be grime.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    On a rainy night, a sad man leaves his home to deliver a letter to someone who recently left him.
  • Presto (2008)
    Review preview for Presto

    Rabbit versus magician may be an ancient and arcane struggle, but rarely has it been so kinetically depicted.

    Andrew Robertson · 4 out of 5
    A stage magician's rabbit rebels. Showing with WALL·E.

News and features

Paul Rowley on moving to New York, the Pulse massacre, and Gays Against Guns

'It was written for him' Declan Recks on comedy drama One Sweet Hour and its late star Gary Lydon

All at sea Max Fisher on refugee journeys, anti-migrant sentiment and Rule, Britannia

Fishing for identity Pete Muller on questions of masculinity and how it passes down the generations in Bucks Harbor

A step ahead of the others Leading Italian filmmakers on the legacy of Robert Rossellini

True to her nature Hanna Bergholm on storytelling, emotional truth and Nightborn

Painting history Pauline Julier and Nicolas Chapoulier on imagining the journey of a 17th century portait in Les Indes

Fatherland leads European Film Awards nominations La Bola Negra hot on its heels

More news and features

Festival coverage

Festivals
Cannes festival coverage, 2026

We're bringing you all the latest news and reviews from the Cheltenham International Film Festival, the Leeds International Film Festival, the Thessaloniki International Film Festival and Tallinn Black Nights.



We're looking forward to the French Film Festival and DOC NYC.



We've recently brought you coverage of the Belfast Film Festival, Halloween Frightfest, the Scottish Queer International Film Festival, Newfest, the London Film Festival, the New York Film Festival and Grimmfest.



Read our full for more.


Visit our festivals section.