Skip to main content

Edinburgh International Film Festival — A–Z of films

2005

  • 0

  • 36
    Review preview for 36

    Directed by Olivier Marchal, an ex-cop himself, the film looks terrific.

    Angus Wolfe Murray · 3.5 out of 5
    Power play and dirty tricks in the French police force.
  • 4
    Review preview for 4

    It's a far more interesting movie to think about than to watch.

    Scott Macdonald · 2 out of 5
    An enigmatic story of modern Russia, given the flavour of myth.
  • Albert Maysles: 3 Shorts
    Review preview for Albert Maysles: 3 Shorts

    The Maysles brothers cleverly capture the vacuousness of the interviewers, clearly chosen more for their looks than their incisive questioning skills.

    Amber Wilkinson · 4 out of 5
    Short documentary records interviews with Marlon Brando, Truman Capote and Muhammad Ali.
  • Angel's Fall
    A young woman tries to break free from life with her father.
  • Antares
    Review preview for Antares

    Antares is another nail in the coffin of brevity.

    Amber Wilkinson · 2 out of 5
    Multi-layered plotlines around the inhabitants of an apartment complex.
  • Antibodies
    Review preview for Antibodies

    A technically assured, well acted and, above all, thought-provoking piece of crossover cinema

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 4.5 out of 5
    A serial killer plays mind games with a policeman.
  • The Aristocrats
    Review preview for The Aristocrats

    Never could the warning, 'Stay away if you're easily offended,' be more appropriate.

    David Stanners · 3.5 out of 5
    Documentary about a filthy joke, told by a succession of professional comedians.
  • The Art Of Losing
    Review preview for The Art Of Losing

    Slickly orchestrated by director Sergio Cabrera with good performances.

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 3.5 out of 5
    Columbian corruption, a decomposing corpse, a hard-drinking reporter and a tearful tart.
  • Astronauts
    Review preview for Astronauts

    Astronauts is a fast, fun film.

    George Williamson · 4 out of 5
    Acid comedy about a junkie trying to clean up.
  • Asylum
    Review preview for Asylum

    So studiously edgy are the performances that one is never quite sure who harbours the darkest pathology.

    Anton Bitel · 4 out of 5
    Infidelity at an institution for the criminally insane.
  • Battle In Heaven
    An ugly taxi driver and the prostitute daughter of a general go at it and at it and (yawn).
  • The Beat That My Heart Skipped
    Review preview for The Beat That My Heart Skipped

    Jacques Audiard's film isn't intended as a replacement for Toback's wild-eyed and masterly [Fingers], but rather a deliberately assured take on the same material.

    Scott Macdonald · 3.5 out of 5
    A young heavy, following in his father's violent footsteps yearns for something more.
  • Black Narcissus
    Review preview for Black Narcissus

    Perfectly controlled lighting simulates the thin air that exhausts the once disciplined sisters.

    Jennie Kermode · 4 out of 5
    A group of nuns struggle to keep order in a remote Himalayan convent.
  • The Business
    Review preview for The Business

    Like the world it portrays, The Business can be criticised as superficial and derivative, but it accurately depicts the headstrong, cheesy glamour of the period.

    Chris · 3.5 out of 5
    In the mid-80s a young man falls foul of a gangster and is sent to take money to an ex-con in Spain, who invites him to join his team.
  • Before The Flood
    Documentary charting the relocation of the people of Fengjie, a city that will shortly be submerged beneath the Yangtze river.
  • A Bittersweet Life
    Review preview for A Bittersweet Life

    All it does is liberally steal pieces from superior films and cobble them together without realising just why those movies worked.

    Scott Macdonald · 1.5 out of 5
    A tale of revenge, infidelity and gangland warfare in South Korea.
  • The Boys Of Baraka
    Review preview for The Boys Of Baraka

    Beautifully captures the kaleidoscopic element of family life.

    Amber Wilkinson · 4.5 out of 5
    Disadvantaged kids from Baltimore are sent to boarding school in Kenya.
  • The Cat Leaves Home
    Review preview for The Cat Leaves Home

    Too cold and distanced.

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 2.5 out of 5
    Two girls fight over men.
  • D

  • The Dark
    Review preview for The Dark

    Unfortunately, it becomes clear that the filmmakers have bitten off more than they can chew.

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 2.5 out of 5
    A Welsh ghost story with watery connections.
  • The Devil's Miner
    Review preview for The Devil's Miner

    A beautiful film, full of courage, determination and optimism.

    Kotleta · 5 out of 5
    Documentary on the child miners of Bolivia.
  • The Devil And Daniel Johnston
    Review preview for The Devil And Daniel Johnston

    Daniel's music is heard throughout, adding immeasurable depth to his story.

    George Williamson · 4.5 out of 5
    Biographical documentary about an underground singer/songwriter extraordinaire.
  • Dominion
    Review preview for Dominion

    Long-winded, overwrought and totally without a climax.

    Gator MacReady · 2 out of 5
    Before The Exorcist came the demon Pazuzu.
  • Dumplings
    Ageing star seeks out an anti-ageing recipe... just don't ask about the special ingredient.
  • Ferpect Crime
    An accidental killing leads to funny consequences of a psychotic nature.
  • Fateless
    Hungarian teenager discovers a certain "happiness" in the Nazi death camps.
  • Fourteen Sucks
    Review preview for Fourteen Sucks

    Fourteen Sucks may be a provocative title, but it's a solid and promising debut.

    Scott Macdonald · 3.5 out of 5
    A teenage rites-of-passage that does not flinch at sexual violation.
  • Frankie
    Review preview for Frankie

    Fabienne Berthaud's film meanders between dissonant, ethereal scenes in the sanatorium and the frenetic action of a photographer's studios... the contrast between these two worlds is absolute.

    George Williamson · 4 out of 5
    A fashion model crumbles beneath the incessant pressure of an ugly industry.
  • Gamblers
    Review preview for Gamblers

    There isn't a whiff of falsehood, or evidence of a set designer's duster.

    Angus Wolfe Murray · 4 out of 5
    Card sharks on the streets of Paris.
  • George A Romero's Land Of The Dead
    Review preview for George A Romero's Land Of The Dead

    Appallingly developed characters and situations decay and rot onscreen.

    Scott Macdonald · 3 out of 5
    The creator of the zombie genre returns with an allegory of Bush's abuses in Iraq.
  • Gone To Earth
    Review preview for Gone To Earth

    With dialogue like this, you don't need a scene at the village fair to reinforce olde worlde cliches of English rural life, but you get it, anyway.

    Angus Wolfe Murray · 2 out of 5
    A barefooted Shropshire lass marries the vicar and is seduced by the squire.
  • Grizzly Man
    Review preview for Grizzly Man

    Anyone who has seen Herzog's Fitzcarraldo will know of the director's fascination with doomed quests and magnificent obsessions, and in Treadwell he has found his dream subject.

    The Exile · 5 out of 5
    Werner Herzog examines the psyche of Timothy Treadwell, a man who lived and died with bears.
  • Guy X
    Review preview for Guy X

    The plot strands are abandoned after the intro, the characters never encouraged to rise above their cardboard.

    Angus Wolfe Murray · 2 out of 5
    Odd goings on at isolated US base in Greenland, as witnessed by a man with two names.
  • Ghosts
    Review preview for Ghosts

    Too enigmatic and slow burning for its own good.

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 2.5 out of 5
    Mystery of a lost child and two teenage girls on the run.
  • The Great Ecstasy Of Robert Carmichael
    Review preview for The Great Ecstasy Of Robert Carmichael

    I’m at a loss to see what Thomas Clay’s point is.

    Jeff Robson · 2 out of 5
    The fall of an intelligent teenager into a life of ultraviolence and depravity.
  • Green Street
    Review preview for Green Street

    Although there's mercifully little football in this, there's also minimal emotional depth.

    Kotleta · 3 out of 5
    A Yank comes to West Ham and learns how to be a hooligan.
  • Gunner Palace
    Review preview for Gunner Palace

    Ultimately, the film fails to show the deeper ways these youngsters will have been affected.

    Chris · 2 out of 5
    The day-to-day life of young American soldiers in Iraq.
  • Gypo
    Review preview for Gypo

    The film connected with me in a way that went beyond suspension of disbelief.

    Chris · 5 out of 5
    The impact of a young Czech refugee on a British working-class family.
  • The Holyrood Files
    Review preview for The Holyrood Files

    A superbly constructed and solid amalgamation of evidence and opinion

    Scott Macdonald · 4 out of 5
    Expose of the building of the Scottish Parliament.
  • I

  • Iron Island
    A society of people live on a derelict oil tanker in the Persian Gulf. Are they being misled?
  • Junebug
    Review preview for Junebug

    Creates hauntingly evocative, empty spaces that bleed history.

    The Exile · 4.5 out of 5
    Love and understanding are tested in a Southern comedy-romance-tragedy.
  • Johanna
    Review preview for Johanna

    Art, or arse? Well, we certainly see plenty of Toth's behind as she orgasms elderly blokes back to health.

    Amber Wilkinson · 2 out of 5
    An operatic hospital saga, in which junkie nurse prescribes sex as life-saving treatment.
  • Keane
    Review preview for Keane

    This is a film that you respect, rather than enjoy.

    Angus Wolfe Murray · 3 out of 5
    Paranoia stalks a bus depot in Jersey as the father of an abducted girl seeks retribution
  • Kinky Boots
    Review preview for Kinky Boots

    It's the same old sentimental tripe that gets rolled out again and again.

    George Williamson · 2.5 out of 5
    Shoemaker opts for drastic footwear design in a bid save family business.
  • Letter From An Unknown Woman
    Review preview for Letter From An Unknown Woman

    A classic three-tissue melodrama.

    Nicola Osborne · 3 out of 5
    A woman falls for her neighbour and maintains her unrequited love down the years.
  • The Life I Want
    Review preview for The Life I Want

    The central performances from Luigi Lo Cascio and Sandra Ceccarelli are sublime, free from the usual heavy handedness used to indicate acting within a film.

    George Williamson · 4 out of 5
    Troubled romance between stars on an Italian film set.
  • L'Intrus
    Review preview for L'Intrus

    No plot, no point, except L'Intrus is consistently exciting to look at.

    Angus Wolfe Murray · 2.5 out of 5
    Plot-defying drama about a naked man, with dogs.
  • M

  • Mad Hot Ballroom
    Review preview for Mad Hot Ballroom

    The film goes a long way on charm alone.

    Scott Macdonald · 4 out of 5
    Competitive ballroom dancing for the ethnically diverse pupils of Washington Heights.
  • Marilyn Hotchkiss' Ballroom Dancing And Charm School
    Review preview for Marilyn Hotchkiss' Ballroom Dancing And Charm School

    What should be a romantic mush cake, with lemon icing and a cherry on top, is treacle pud, with hot fudge and molasses.

    Angus Wolfe Murray · 2 out of 5
    A sad baker helps a dying motorist and discovers that he's not the only one who can't dance.
  • Mirrorball Animation
    Review preview for Mirrorball Animation

    A longer review than I planned, but that's only because there is simply so much good stuff in this collection of animated shorts that anything less wouldn't have done it justice.

    George Williamson · 4.5 out of 5
    A collection of the best animated music videos that 2005 had to offer.
  • Mirrorball Best Of The Best
    Review preview for Mirrorball Best Of The Best

    A fantastic nostalgic trip.

    George Williamson · 4.5 out of 5
    The second selection of new promo videos from Mirrorball.
  • Mirrorball - Fresh Tracks 1
    Review preview for Mirrorball - Fresh Tracks 1

    This latest season of Fresh Tracks sometimes seems a little stale.

    George Williamson · 3 out of 5
    A selection of new promo videos from Mirrorball.
  • Mirrorball - Fresh Tracks 2
    Review preview for Mirrorball - Fresh Tracks 2

    Memorable videos include Evan Bernard's inspired A-Z of drugs stereotypes promo for Soulwax - it's an alphabetic cornucopia of narcotics and their effects.

    George Williamson · 3.5 out of 5
    The second selection of new promo videos from Mirrorball.
  • Mirrorball KeepInTime
    Turntablists meet the drummers from the records that they spin.
  • Mirrorball Made In Japan
    Bizarre and brilliant creations from the Far East.
  • MirrorMask
    Review preview for MirrorMask

    McKean's vision has a truly dreamlike quality.

    Amber Wilkinson · 3.5 out of 5
    A circus girl falls into a fantasy world where darkness threatens the kingdom of light.
  • The Magician
    Review preview for The Magician

    For a film shot in 10 days on a budget of around $3000, it's quite an achievement.

    George Williamson · 3.5 out of 5
    Documentary filmmaker follows a Melbourne thug about his business.
  • A Matter Of Life And Death
    Review preview for A Matter Of Life And Death

    Undoubtedly one of the best films ever made.

    Scott Macdonald · 5 out of 5
    A wartime aviator begs a celestial court to let him escape death so he can be with the woman he loves. Out on re-issue in cinemas.
  • Morke
    Review preview for Morke

    A good 25 minutes could have been trimmed off the length without anyone noticing.

    Scott Macdonald · 1.5 out of 5
    Danish mystery about serial suicides.
  • Night Watch
    Review preview for Night Watch

    Heredia is fresh and perfectly cast as the hyperactive rent boy and his vital energy really pushes the film along, making up for the fairly ordinary cinematography and shaky camera work.

    George Williamson · 3.5 out of 5
    A streetwalker roaming the streets of Buenos Aires meets long dead friends.
  • One Long Winter Without Fire
    Review preview for One Long Winter Without Fire

    A startling work that teaches the redemptive power of self-forgiveness

    Scott Macdonald · 4 out of 5
    A beautifully composed tale about redemption and coping with loss.
  • One Nite In Mongkok
    Review preview for One Nite In Mongkok

    While handling the action with aplomb - the violence is low-key but high-impact.

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 4.5 out of 5
    Triad tensions in Hong Kong bring a hired assassin from the mainland.
  • On A Clear Day
    Review preview for On A Clear Day

    Mullan brings a gruff, no-nonsense persona to his role, making Frank's emotional journey well worth taking.

    Tony Sullivan · 4 out of 5
    A redundant shipworker from Glasgow dreams of swimming the English Channel.
  • P
    Review preview for P

    The combination of a hard-hitting expose of Thai prostitution with genre horror may sound intriguing on paper, but the result emerges as an oil and water mix.

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 2 out of 5
    Thai country girl uses terror magic in Bangkok go-go bar.
  • Police Beat
    Review preview for Police Beat

    Police Beat is a strange little film. Niang is stiff and wooden at times, but, at others, the flow is perfect.

    George Williamson · 3 out of 5
    The life of a Seattle cop, who worries more about his personal life than city crime.
  • Popular Music
    Review preview for Popular Music

    The film feels fractured, with bizarre transitions and editing, which often leave you wondering quite what's going on.

    George Williamson · 2.5 out of 5
    In the Swedish backwoods rock-and-roll becomes act of rebellion for pubescent teenagers.
  • Peeping Tom
    Review preview for Peeping Tom

    Peeping Tom is a film all about watching and identification, a film whose real horror hinges on the way it implicates the audience in its dark voyeurism.

    Jennie Kermode · 4.5 out of 5
    A young photographer becomes fascinated by expressions of fear, with deadly consequences.
  • Pucker Up
    Review preview for Pucker Up

    Hard to recommend, really, unless you enjoy hearing classics, such as Cavalleria Rusticana: Intermezzo, being murdered.

    Scott Macdonald · 2 out of 5
    A competitive whistling documentary from Louisburg, North Carolina.
  • The Puffy Chair
    Review preview for The Puffy Chair

    Realistic and deeply heartfelt.

    George Williamson · 4.5 out of 5
    Surprisingly real road trip movie about a quest to find a piece of furniture.
  • R

  • Radiant
    Review preview for Radiant

    The film is so preposterously overwrought and mundane that it's hard to imagine that writer/director Steve Mahone could overlook such obvious dullness.

    Gator MacReady · 1.5 out of 5
    A new vaccine creates a deadly virus.
  • Rag Tale
    Review preview for Rag Tale

    After 15 minutes of fast zooms, sliced cuts, topsy pans and turvy close ups you want to be sick... after 40 minutes, you have eaten your words and are beginning to think this is original and thrilling.

    Angus Wolfe Murray · 4 out of 5
    Poisonous cynicism and manipulative scheming at the heart of a national tabloid.
  • The Red Shoes
    Review preview for The Red Shoes

    The dance sequences are brilliantly performed and well worth watching the film for in their own right.

    Jennie Kermode · 4.5 out of 5
    A dancer is torn between the man she loves and her obsessive commitment to her craft.
  • Salesman
    Following four door-to-door salesmen around the States in the late Sixties.
  • Saltire Society Award For Short Documentary
    Review preview for Saltire Society Award For Short Documentary

    These are all good films - some traditional, some genuinely different and new.

    George Williamson · 4 out of 5
    A collection of the best of Scottish short documentaries from the last year competing for the Saltire Society Award
  • Same Sex America
    Review preview for Same Sex America

    A slick, professional and worthwhile piece of work.

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 3 out of 5
    Investigating gay marriage.
  • Saraband
    Review preview for Saraband

    Saraband, in true Bergman tradition, wrestles with human relationships, using a slow pace, pointed dialogue, and heavy symbolism to explore the psychological states of the characters.

    Chris · 4.5 out of 5
    Ingmar Bergman returns to Scenes From A Marriage 30 years on.
  • Screaming Masterpiece
    Review preview for Screaming Masterpiece

    Elegiacally epic camerawork sweeps over the snow-kissed landscape as lovingly as the man in a funny woolly hat plays Viking songs about Odin on his xylophone.

    Kotleta · 4.5 out of 5
    A look at the Icelandic music industry, its roots and stars.
  • Snuff Movie
    Review preview for Snuff Movie

    If this is what his 'film is dead, long live cinema' manifesto comes down to, then stop the future I want off...

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 1.5 out of 5
    Psychodrama by horror auteur Boris Arkadin.
  • Song Of Songs
    Review preview for Song Of Songs

    A challenging, powerful and thought-provoking piece of cinema.

    Keith Hennessey Brown · 4 out of 5
    The stirrings of incestuous passion against a background of deeply felt religious beliefs.
  • Serenity
    Review preview for Serenity

    Knowing, loving, kidding and one of the year's best films.

    Scott Macdonald · 5 out of 5
    Buffy's creator does battle with the Reavers in space, as earthlings move off their overcrowded planet.
  • Shakespeare Behind Bars
    Review preview for Shakespeare Behind Bars

    Stirring and creatively wrought

    Scott Macdonald · 4 out of 5
    Murderers and rapists perform Shakespeare and learn forgiveness.
  • Stoned
    Review preview for Stoned

    Despite good performances all round (Gregory is very sympathetic), it does get boring.

    Gator MacReady · 3 out of 5
    The last days of the fifth Rolling Stone, Brian Jones.
  • Sugar
    Review preview for Sugar

    As a surreal piece, it feels too much like a horror film, and viewed as a horror film, it lacks direction.

    George Williamson · 1.5 out of 5
    A horrific discovery in a one room apartment leads into a surreal, claustrophobic nightmare.
  • The Sun
    Review preview for The Sun

    A fascinating film, rich in unspoken detail.

    Scott Macdonald · 3.5 out of 5
    One of Emperor Hirohito last days before the Japanese surrender in 1945.
  • Taimagura Grandma
    Review preview for Taimagura Grandma

    While a sense of place is important, lingering (and not very good) shots of the local wildlife are really superfluous.

    Amber Wilkinson · 3 out of 5
    Documentary examining a vanishing way of life in Japan.
  • The Tales Of Hoffmann
    Review preview for The Tales Of Hoffmann

    The passage of time - and a beautiful 4k restoration - have been kind to this reimagining of Jacques Offenbach's opera, with its deliberately operatic gestures and colours and stylised production design feeling sharply avant garde even today.

    Amber Wilkinson · 4 out of 5
    A poet recalls three doomed romances.
  • Tartan Shorts
    Review preview for Tartan Shorts

    Overall, I am not highly impressed.

    Gator MacReady · 3 out of 5
    Selection of shorts from the Ediburgh Film Festival.
  • Thumbsucker
    Review preview for Thumbsucker

    The setting may be small-town, but this is a vision in microcosm of a whole nation that has been driven inevitably towards anxiety and unease by self-imposed pressures and impossible aspirations.

    Anton Bitel · 4 out of 5
    Teenager from the 'burbs attempts to quit suckin'.
  • Tickets
    Review preview for Tickets

    The trans-European train on which the film's sections unfold is the perfect setting for such a synergistic venture.

    Anton Bitel · 3 out of 5
    Three international film directors take a train to Rome and tell stories of love, loss and the beautiful game.
  • Tour De Force
    Review preview for Tour De Force

    Lacking both gravitas and focus.

    David Stanners · 2.5 out of 5
    A strong man heads for Russia to build on his 23 Guinness Book of Records titles.
  • Tsotsi
    Review preview for Tsotsi

    There is not a hint of artificiality, studio mock-ups, or designer poverty here.

    Angus Wolfe Murray · 5 out of 5
    An outstanding, highly moral tale of a young South African thug's redemption.
  • Up And Down
    Review preview for Up And Down

    An ambitious premise that only just falls short of genius.

    Amber Wilkinson · 4 out of 5
    Satire of racism and xenophobia in modern Prague.
  • V

  • Voices Of Iraq
    Review preview for Voices Of Iraq

    The documentary fills a necessary gap in our understanding as long as it is not viewed unquestioningly.

    Chris · 3.5 out of 5
    Iraqis film each other. Americans edit it. The invasion is given the thumbs up.
  • Wah-Wah
    Review preview for Wah-Wah

    A delight from beginning to end.

    Jennie Kermode · 4.5 out of 5
    A boy grows up in a broken family as the winds of change blow through Swaziland.
  • The Wedding
    Review preview for The Wedding

    The Wedding is a delightful satire on Polish marriage traditions but much of what it features is so universal that people all over the world will be able to identify with it.

    Jennie Kermode · 4 out of 5
    A wedding reception where everyone has a secret descends into dark farce.
  • Weekdays
    Review preview for Weekdays

    The dialogue is sparse and when the characters do speak, it's clunkily written, laden with insipid profundities, and often badly delivered.

    George Williamson · 2.5 out of 5
    An unknown woman goes about her daily life - clubbing, fucking and lunch with grandma.
  • Les Yeux Clairs
    Review preview for Les Yeux Clairs

    Boutefeu's wonderful acting paints a vivid portrait.

    George Williamson · 4 out of 5
    Well-acted drama about a sheltered bipolar girl who inadvertantly goes on a road-trip.